In our daily lives, we frequently rely on charts to communicate complex ideas succinctly. As the old saying goes, "A picture is worth a thousand words," suggesting that a single image can express intricate and sometimes multiple concepts more effectively than extensive verbal explanations.
However, this introduces a challenge: determining the most effective way to convey ideas through imagery. This includes choosing the appropriate type of graph, color scheme, annotations, or deciding whether to use a simple depiction of facts or a narrative derived from the data.During my tenure as a Data Scientist, exploratory data analysis (EDA) was a crucial phase in deciphering data. Before moving on to the modeling phase, I was tasked with presenting my findings to colleagues and clients. My goal was always to identify patterns and hidden insights in the data, which would then validate further modeling. In this process, I also aimed to integrate domain-specific knowledge for two main reasons: to enhance model performance and to make the information more relatable for clients. This experience led me to realize the importance of data storytelling, which goes beyond mere modeling.
I have been particularly intrigued by the progress in the UX field, especially by the contributions of renowned figures like Don Norman and Edward Tufte. Inspired by their work in UX design, I sought to apply these principles to data visualization. My objective is to narrate stories through data, moving beyond the mere presentation of numbers, thereby reducing cognitive overload for the audience. Let's delve into my insights and observations on blending UX principles with data storytelling.
Revitalizing Chart Design: Beyond the Basics
At the core, charts are meant to be clarity and comprehension, swooping in to present data in a digestible, easy-to-understand format. A well-crafted chart should communicate its message quickly and effectively, steering clear of any confusion or misinterpretation. But here's where the plot thickens.
Imagine stepping into the shoes of someone not steeped in tech jargon or the nuances of data analysis. This shift in perspective is crucial. Not everyone has the luxury of understanding the intricacies of a chart as intuitively as a tech aficionado might. The goal of visualization is to be self-explanatory; it's not practical to attach a human guide to every chart. And let's be honest, if you have to write an essay to explain your chart, hasn't the chart already missed its mark? Another aspect I would like to discuss is "accessibility". Consider the diverse audience, including those who are colorblind—a condition affecting a significant slice of the population. Making your charts accessible means ensuring they're user-friendly for everyone, from color contrasts and text alternatives to screen reader compatibility.
Now, let's dive into the user's perspective, where time and attention are often in short supply. In the bustling corridors of business or the critical moments of research, "efficiency" in chart design is not just a buzzword; it's a lifeline. A well-designed chart empowers users to quickly distill essential facts and trends, paving the way for informed decisions and impactful "effective decision-making."
“The real problem with the interface is that it is an interface. Interfaces get in the way. I don’t want to focus my energies on an interface. I want to focus on the job” -Don Norman
Engaging users with your charts is another piece of the puzzle. By highlighting key information upfront and inviting deeper exploration, you create a platform for discovery. This approach can spark user "engagement," potentially unveiling insights even the creator might not have noticed. But how do we keep this engagement alive across various platforms?
Consider the myriad ways users interact with data: from presentations (admittedly, not the most thrilling medium) to web pages accessible on a spectrum of devices. This diversity demands "adaptability to different contexts," ensuring that your charts deliver their message effectively, whether viewed on a smartphone or a desktop.
Then there's the matter of "branding." Many organizations have strict branding guidelines, including color schemes that charts need to adhere to. Aligning your charts with these guidelines isn't just about following rules; it's about maintaining "consistency" in communication. This consistency reinforces the organization's professional image and ensures that users don't get lost in translation due to stylistic discrepancies.
Finally, we arrive at "User Satisfaction and Trust." When charts are intuitive and straightforward, user satisfaction with the tool or platform skyrockets. This satisfaction fosters trust in the data and, by extension, in the organization behind it. It's a testament to the power of clear, accurate communication in building a reliable relationship with your audience.
In sum, the "UX of Charting" is not a mere afterthought but a foundational aspect of chart creation. It's about crafting an experience that's as insightful as it is inclusive, ensuring that your charts don't just convey data but tell a story that resonates with every viewer. Remember, at the heart of every chart is a narrative waiting to unfold, and it's our job to make sure that narrative is accessible, engaging, and ultimately, enlightening.
What are the UX aspects of charting ?
As we address the issue at hand, let's explore the UX principles, philosophies, and aspects integral to charting.
Essentials of Chart Design
At the heart of effective chart design is a user-centric approach. Imagine you're crafting a map, not for seasoned explorers, but for those who are about to embark on their first adventure. You wouldn't clutter this map with every possible path or landmark. Instead, you'd highlight the most relevant routes, ensuring they lead to the desired destination effortlessly. This is where understanding your audience—through user personas, stories, and flows—becomes invaluable. It's about anticipating the needs, expertise level, and the specific tasks your audience will undertake using the data presented.
Next up is the cornerstone of any data visualization: data accuracy and integrity. Picture a mirror designed to reflect an undistorted image. If the mirror is warped, the reflection is no longer true. The same goes for charts. They must be the unwarped mirror that accurately reflects the underlying data. Avoid the pitfalls of misleading scales or cherry-picked data that could distort the viewer's understanding. Integrity in design ensures the trustworthiness of your charts.
The significance of contextual relevance cannot be overstated. A chart, much like a guidebook, should be tailored to its context. This means enriching your charts with annotations, explanations, or references that anchor the data in its real-world application. It's about giving users the 'why' behind the 'what,' enabling them to grasp the full picture and understand the data within its proper setting.
Empathy for the end user is what transforms a good chart into a great one. Just as a skilled guide understands the fears, capabilities, and expectations of their group, a chart designer must tune into the end user's perspective. This might involve user testing and gathering feedback, a process that sheds light on how real people interact with your charts, revealing insights that can significantly refine your design.
Lastly, the art of storytelling with data elevates a chart from a mere graphical representation to a narrative that engages, informs, and persuades. Good storytelling in chart design doesn't just throw numbers at the viewer; it guides them on a journey through the data, highlighting landmarks (key points) along the way and helping them arrive at meaningful conclusions. It's about making the data not just seen, but also felt and understood.
"Content precedes design. Design in the absence of content is not design, it’s decoration."-Jeffrey Zeldman
Principles of Chart Design and Visualization
When it comes to designing charts, it's like being an architect of information, where every decision from structure to aesthetic detail affects how well the audience understands and interacts with the data presented. Let's walk through the essentials of crafting charts that not only inform but engage and enlighten.
Choosing the right type of chart is our starting point. Imagine you're at a crossroads, and each path represents a different chart type—bar charts for comparisons, line charts for trends over time, pie charts for proportions. The path you choose should lead your audience to the intended insight with clarity and precision, avoiding any detours into confusion or misinterpretation.
Now, let's talk color and contrast. These are the paints with which we'll bring our chart to life. Colors are not just decorative; they're functional, helping to differentiate data points and categories. However, wielding this palette requires mindfulness about color blindness and ensuring sufficient contrast for readability. It's like dressing up your data in a way that's not just appealing but accessible to all.
Legibility and typography are where the rubber meets the road in terms of readability. The text in your charts—axis labels, legends, annotations—shouldn't require a magnifying glass to read. It's about choosing the right font size, style, and color that make your text stand out, yet not crowd out the data it's meant to describe.
Speaking of accessibility, this is where we ensure no user is left behind. Whether it's through alternative text descriptions for visual elements or ensuring compatibility with screen readers, making your charts accessible is akin to opening the doors wide, welcoming everyone into the world of data you're presenting.
Interactivity can turn a static chart into an engaging dialogue with the user. Tools like tooltips, zooming, and filtering invite users to dive deeper, explore, and connect with the data on their terms. It's like handing them a flashlight to illuminate the aspects they're most curious about, but it's crucial that this exploration feels more like a guided tour than a maze.
Responsiveness in chart design ensures that your masterpiece looks just as intended, whether it's on a giant monitor or a smartphone screen. In today's digital age, your chart needs to be a chameleon, adaptable to the environment it finds itself in, ensuring clarity and functionality across all devices.
Performance is key, especially for web-based charts. In a fast-paced world, waiting for a chart to load can feel like watching paint dry. Optimizing for quick loading times and smooth interactivity is essential, lest user engagement drops off before the data even has a chance to make its mark.
Contextual clarity is about setting the scene. Titles, subtitles, and explanatory texts are your narrative tools, setting up the story your data tells. This context guides your audience through the chart, highlighting the plot points and revelations along the way.
Embracing simplicity and minimalism in chart design helps to avoid overwhelming your audience with TMI (too much information). By stripping down to the essentials, you focus their attention on what matters most, making the data's story clearer and more compelling.
Customization options give your audience a bit of the director's chair, allowing them to tweak the view to their liking or explore different aspects of the data. This personal touch can make the experience more relevant and engaging for them.
Finally, consistency across your charts creates a cohesive narrative thread, making the journey through your data a smooth ride. Consistent use of colors, fonts, and layouts not only strengthens your brand but also reinforces the reliability and professionalism of the information presented.
In crafting charts, we're not just data analysts or designers; we're storytellers, educators, and guides. Our mission is to illuminate the path through complex information, making the journey insightful, accessible, and, yes, even enjoyable for our audience.
Applying Don Norman's Principles to Chart Design
Don Norman emerges as a key figure in the realm of User-Centered Design, an approach that puts a premium on crafting products with the end-user's comprehension and usage at the forefront. Through his extensive contributions to design, usability, and cognitive science, Norman has fundamentally influenced our understanding of user-centered design principles and their application in technology interactions. His seminal work, "The Design of Everyday Things," stands as a cornerstone text in the field of UX, transcending specific domains and offering valuable insights for a broad spectrum of design challenges. Given the universal applicability of Norman's principles, let's explore how they can be integrated into the art of chart design.
Leveraging Affordances in Charts
“Affordances provide strong clues to the operations of things. Plates are for pushing. Knobs are for turning. Slots are for inserting things into. Balls are for throwing or bouncing”
Starting with the concept of affordances, imagine a chart not just as a static representation of data but as an interactive playground. Affordances in chart design suggest to the user how elements can be interacted with. A clickable legend, for example, invites users to engage with the data, allowing them to explore different layers of information with ease. It's about making the functionalities of a chart as intuitive as picking up a ball to throw.
The Role of Signifiers in Data Visualization
“Signifiers signal things, in particular, what actions are possible and how they should be done”
Signifiers in data visualization serve as beacons, guiding users on how to navigate and interpret the chart. These could be axis labels that clearly demarcate what each axis represents, grid lines that help quantify data points, or hover effects that beckon for interaction, offering more detailed information. Signifiers are the subtle nudges that enhance the user's journey through data.
Intuitive Mapping for Effective Interaction
“when mapping uses spatial correspondence between the layout of the controls and the devices being controlled, it is easy to determine how to use them.”
Mapping in chart design ensures a seamless and intuitive interaction between the user and the visualization. When a user manipulates a filter or a slider, the immediate and corresponding visual change in the chart mirrors the simplicity of turning a knob to adjust the volume on a radio. The relationship between action and reaction is clear and logical, making the exploration of data feel natural.
Providing Feedback to Users
“Feedback—sending back to the user information about what action has actually been done, what result has been accomplished—is a well-known concept in the science of control and information theory”
Feedback is a critical dialogue between the chart and its user. It confirms interactions, whether it's highlighting a selected data point or presenting a detailed tooltip. This immediate response is akin to a conversation, where the chart acknowledges the user's queries and provides answers, reinforcing the engagement and ensuring the user's actions have tangible outcomes.
Implementing Constraints to Guide Users
“Physical constraints are closely related to real affordances: For example, it is not possible to move the cursor outside the screen: this is a physical constraint. Locking the mouse button when clicking is not desired would be a physical constraint.”
Constraints in chart design act as guardrails, guiding users towards meaningful interactions while preventing confusion or misuse. By limiting how far one can zoom into a time-series chart, for instance, we prevent the user from drowning in a sea of granular data that offers little insight. It's about creating a safe exploration space where users can navigate without losing sight of valuable information.
Conceptual Models
“A conceptual model is an explanation, usually highly simplified, of how something works. It doesn’t have to be complete or even accurate as long as it is useful.”
Conceptual models underpin the user's understanding of a chart. Designing with these mental models in mind means creating visualizations that align with users' pre-existing knowledge and expectations. A sales chart that intuitively progresses from left to right and positions higher values as better performance taps into these mental models, making the data instantly understandable.
Error Tolerance
“To me, error analysis is the sweet spot for improvement.”
Designing for error tolerance is about acknowledging that to err is human, and the design should accommodate this inevitability. Instead of punishing users for incompatible data selections, the chart could offer suggestions or corrections, turning potential frustration into an opportunity for learning and exploration.
Prioritizing User-Centered Design
“User-centered design means working with your users all throughout the project”
User-centered design, as Norman espouses, is about embedding the user's perspective into every stage of the design process. It involves creating charts that not only convey data but do so in a way that is accessible, intuitive, and meaningful to the end user, regardless of their technical expertise.
Enhancing Discoverability in Charts
“Two of the most important characteristics of good design are discoverability and understanding”.
Discoverability and understanding are the twin pillars of effective chart design. They ensure that users can not only find the information they need but also comprehend it. Interactive elements like tooltips and legends play a pivotal role here, acting as guides that lead users to insights.
Simplicity and Intuitiveness
“Simplicity design axiom: The complexity of the information appliance is that of the task, not the tool. The technology is invisible.”
Finally, simplicity and intuitiveness are the hallmarks of great design. In the context of charts, this means choosing familiar formats and avoiding unnecessary complexity. It's about making the tool—a bar chart for comparisons or a line chart for trends—disappear behind the task, allowing users to focus on the insights rather than grappling with the visualization tool itself.
Crafting Narratives with Data Visualization
Exploring the narrative potential of charts, we delve into how they can turn abstract data into compelling visual stories, aiding in the identification of trends, patterns, and anomalies. The key to effective data storytelling lies in choosing the appropriate chart types—line charts for illustrating trends, bar charts for comparisons, and pie charts for demonstrating proportions—to suit the narrative context at hand.
The next step involves crafting the narrative. A compelling data story navigates the audience through the dataset, beginning with the context (the significance of the data), followed by the presentation (what the data reveals), and culminating in the derivation of insights or actions (the implications of the data). This approach not only makes visualizations more engaging but also more memorable, transforming charts from mere informational tools to vehicles of engagement. The use of color, size, and layout is pivotal in maintaining audience interest and facilitating an immediate understanding of the story. Emphasizing again, the most impactful data stories are those that are both simple and clear, steering clear of clutter to present data in a direct and accessible manner.
As we stand on the cusp of technological advancement, the future of data storytelling beckons with promising and exciting possibilities. With devices like the Magic Leap hinting at a future where augmented reality (AR) and virtual reality (VR) become everyday tools, we're on the brink of a new era in data presentation. Imagine a scenario where audiences can "walk through" data stories, interact with 3D chart models, and witness the ebb and flow of trends in an immersive environment. This leap from flat screens to interactive, spatial experiences could revolutionize how we understand and engage with data, making complex information not just accessible but truly experiential.
The evolution from hand-drawn maps to interactive digital visualizations and, looking ahead, to AR and VR environments, marks a thrilling journey in the realm of data storytelling. As we explore these new frontiers, the principles of user-centered design, clarity, and engagement remain our guiding lights, ensuring that regardless of how advanced the technology gets, our data stories will always be human-centric, understandable, and, above all, compelling. The future of data storytelling is bright, and I, for one, am eager to see where this journey takes us.
Iconic Historical Visualizations
Here are some of the great visualizations from the past.
Napoleon's 1812 March by Minard: Often hailed as one of the most informative statistical graphics, Minard’s chart of Napoleon's disastrous Russian campaign of 1812 combines multiple data sets into a single illustration. This visualization masterfully depicts the size of Napoleon's army at different points along their march to and from Moscow, alongside the harsh temperatures they endured, showcasing an exemplary use of graphical excellence to convey complex information.
John Snow's Cholera Map: Another seminal work is John Snow's cholera map from 1854. By mapping the locations of cholera deaths and public water pumps in London, Snow's work utilized stacked bars to effectively communicate the correlation between water source locations and cholera outbreaks. This graphic not only made the data easily understandable but also revealed crucial insights that led to significant public health interventions.
The Visual Display of Quantitative Information - Edward Tufte
Before concluding this discussion, it's essential to acknowledge Edward Tufte's profound impact on the field of data visualization. An American statistician, artist, and professor emeritus at Yale University, Tufte's "The Visual Display of Quantitative Information" stands as a major milestone in understanding how to design clear, efficient, and honest graphics for quantitative data presentation. Tufte emphasizes the importance of allowing the data to speak, minimizing non-data ink (i.e., reducing clutter), and integrating statistical and verbal descriptions to create compelling narratives within charts, graphs, and tables. The book is celebrated for its insightful analysis of graphical excellence, the critique of common design errors, and its advocacy for the use of high-resolution data displays that communicate complex ideas with precision and clarity. Tufte’s principles have profoundly influenced the fields of data visualization, information design, and statistical graphics.
"Graphical excellence is that which gives to the viewer the greatest number of ideas in the shortest time with the least ink in the smallest space." -Edward R. Tufte
Here is the Keynote by Dr Edward Tufte on TechState summit.
Commentaires